VAT Exemption on Fuel Prices: Supreme Court Ruling in Indo Burma Petroleum Corp. Ltd. vs. Commissioner VAT Delhi

The case of Indo Burma Petroleum Corp. Ltd. vs. Commissioner VAT Delhi & Ors. revolves around a dispute regarding the exemption of Value Added Tax (VAT) on increased fuel prices in Delhi. This landmark judgment provides clarity on tax exemptions, rollback provisions, and how VAT should be applied when fuel prices fluctuate.

Background of the Case

The controversy began in June 2006, when the prices of petrol and high-speed diesel were increased by Rs.4/- and Rs.2/- per litre, respectively. This led to an automatic increase in VAT at the ad valorem rate, further raising fuel prices. To provide relief to consumers, the Government of the National Capital Territory of Delhi issued a Memorandum on June 20, 2006, stating:

“VAT shall not be charged on the incremental prices of petrol and diesel as announced by the Government of India with effect from June 6, 2006.”

As a result, oil companies were instructed to continue charging VAT on pre-revised fuel prices, effectively exempting the additional VAT imposed due to the price hike.

Legislative Changes and Ordinance

To formalize the exemption, an Ordinance was promulgated on June 21, 2006, adding a proviso to the definition of “Sale Price” under Section 2(1)(zd) of the Delhi Value Added Tax Act, 2004. The proviso explicitly stated:

“An amount equal to the increase in the prices of petrol and diesel (including the duties and levies charged by the Central Government) taking effect from June 6, 2006, shall not form part of the sale price of petrol and diesel sold on and after the date of promulgation of this Ordinance.”

On November 24, 2006, the Delhi Value Added Tax (Amendment) Act, 2006 replaced the Ordinance, continuing the VAT exemption.

Rollback of Fuel Prices

On November 30, 2006, the government implemented a partial rollback of fuel prices, reducing them slightly. By February 16, 2007, the fuel prices were fully restored to their pre-June 6, 2006 levels.

Despite this rollback, the oil companies continued to apply VAT as if the June 6, 2006, price hike was still in effect. Essentially, they deducted Rs.4/- per litre on petrol and Rs.2/- per litre on diesel from the prevailing sale price and calculated VAT on this reduced amount.

Tax Authorities’ Action

On June 5, 2007, the Delhi Government issued a notification stating that the VAT exemption under the first proviso of Section 2(1)(zd) of the Act would cease to be effective from the date of publication in the Gazette.

Following this, in October 2007, the VAT authorities issued default notices to the oil companies, demanding VAT and penalties for underpayment of tax. The notices stated:

“The oil companies, even after the reduction in fuel prices, have not paid VAT on an amount equal to the price increase of June 6, 2006, which is not in accordance with the law.”

Objections by the Oil Companies

The oil companies challenged these notices before the Additional Commissioner, Trade and Taxes, Delhi. Their main argument was that since the VAT exemption was calculated based on the price increase from June 6, 2006, they were entitled to continue applying the same deduction even after the rollback.

However, the Additional Commissioner, in an order dated August 4, 2008, rejected their objections, stating:

“The exemption was intended only to offset the VAT impact of the price increase on June 6, 2006. Once fuel prices were rolled back, the exemption ceased to be applicable. The oil companies cannot continue deducting Rs.4/- and Rs.2/- indefinitely.”

Appeal Before the VAT Tribunal

The oil companies appealed to the VAT Tribunal, which upheld the tax demand but set aside the penalties. The Tribunal ruled that:

• VAT must be charged on the actual sale price.
• The exemption was linked to the June 6, 2006, price increase and did not extend beyond the rollback.
• The oil companies had misunderstood the scope of the exemption.

High Court Ruling

The companies then appealed to the Delhi High Court, which upheld the Tribunal’s decision. The High Court ruled:

“The exemption under the proviso was meant to relieve consumers from the burden of additional VAT due to the price increase on June 6, 2006. When fuel prices were rolled back, the exemption ceased to apply. The oil companies were incorrect in continuing to apply the VAT exemption after the rollback.”

Supreme Court Judgment

Finally, the oil companies appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that:

• The VAT exemption was a fixed benefit that should continue regardless of later price changes.
• They should be allowed to deduct Rs.4/- and Rs.2/- from the sale price while calculating VAT, even after the rollback.

The Supreme Court, comprising Chief Justice T. S. Thakur and Justice Uday Umesh Lalit, dismissed the appeal and upheld the rulings of the High Court and VAT Tribunal.

The Court ruled:

“The exemption was granted only to offset the VAT burden from the price hike on June 6, 2006. Once the rollback occurred, there was no longer any price increase to justify the exemption. The companies must pay VAT on the actual sale price after the rollback.”

Implications of the Judgment

This ruling has several key implications:

• Clarifies the scope of VAT exemptions: Exemptions tied to specific price hikes do not continue indefinitely if the price hike is reversed.
• Ensures transparency in tax application: Businesses must charge VAT based on actual sale prices, without artificially reducing the tax base.
• Prevents tax revenue loss: If oil companies had continued their interpretation, it would have led to substantial revenue losses for the government.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court’s ruling in this case underscores the importance of correctly interpreting tax exemptions. While the government aimed to protect consumers from an ad valorem VAT hike, this benefit was not meant to be a permanent reduction in VAT liability. This decision provides clarity on how tax benefits should be applied and ensures that tax laws are interpreted in line with legislative intent.

Don’t miss out on the full details! Download the complete judgment in PDF format below and gain valuable insights instantly!

Download Judgment: Indo Burma Petroleum vs Commissioner VAT Del Supreme Court of India Judgment Dated 13-05-2016-1741860866559.pdf

Direct Downlaod Judgment: Direct downlaod this Judgment

See all petitions in GST Law
See all petitions in Tax Refund Disputes
See all petitions in Judgment by T.S. Thakur
See all petitions in Judgment by Uday Umesh Lalit
See all petitions in dismissed
See all petitions in supreme court of India judgments May 2016
See all petitions in 2016 judgments

See all posts in Taxation and Financial Cases Category
See all allowed petitions in Taxation and Financial Cases Category
See all Dismissed petitions in Taxation and Financial Cases Category
See all partially allowed petitions in Taxation and Financial Cases Category