Supreme Court Rules on Mechanical Engineers’ Membership Certificate: No Degree Equivalence

The Supreme Court of India, in the case of Institution of Mechanical Engineers (India) vs. State of Punjab & Ors., addressed the validity of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers (IME) membership certificate for employment purposes. The ruling clarified that the membership certificate issued by IME cannot be considered equivalent to a degree in Mechanical Engineering from a recognized university.

Background of the Case

The Institution of Mechanical Engineers (India), a registered society, conducted examinations leading to the certification of its members as Associate Members of the Institution of Engineers (AMIE). The issue at hand was whether this certification could be treated as equivalent to a formal degree in Mechanical Engineering, particularly for employment in government services.

The case was initially heard by the Punjab and Haryana High Court, which ruled against the recognition of IME’s membership certification as a valid engineering degree. The IME challenged this decision before the Supreme Court, arguing that past government notifications had recognized its certification for employment in the public sector.

Key Legal Issues

Whether the IME membership certificate qualifies as a degree in Mechanical Engineering.
Whether past government notifications recognizing IME’s certification still hold validity under current laws.
Whether the Supreme Court’s ruling in the Orissa Lift Irrigation Corporation case applies to this matter.

Arguments by the Appellant (Institution of Mechanical Engineers)

The IME argued:

Its certification had been recognized by the Government of India since 1976 for employment in government services.
The institution conducted rigorous examinations and training, meeting technical education standards.
The High Court’s ruling was inconsistent with past decisions that upheld the validity of IME’s certification.
The AICTE’s (All India Council for Technical Education) recent stance should not nullify earlier government recognition.

Arguments by the Respondents (State of Punjab & Ors.)

The respondents countered:

The IME was not a university and had no legal authority to grant degrees.
The AICTE and University Grants Commission (UGC) had not approved IME’s programs as equivalent to a degree.
The IME’s certifications did not involve structured education and practical training comparable to accredited engineering degrees.
The Supreme Court’s ruling in the Orissa Lift Irrigation case clearly established that technical education must be regulated by the AICTE.

Supreme Court’s Observations

1. Non-Recognition of IME Certification as a Degree

The Court ruled that the IME’s membership certificate could not be considered equivalent to a formal degree in Mechanical Engineering:

“The Institution of Mechanical Engineers (India) is a registered society and not a recognized university or technical institution under the AICTE Act. The certificate it awards does not fulfill the statutory requirements of a degree in Mechanical Engineering.”

2. Supremacy of AICTE and UGC Regulations

The Court emphasized that technical education must be regulated under the AICTE Act and the UGC Act:

“The AICTE is the sole repository of power to lay down parameters or qualitative norms for technical education. A degree in engineering cannot be conferred by any institution that lacks AICTE approval.”

3. Validity of Past Government Notifications

The Court noted that while past government notifications had recognized IME’s certification, such recognition was conditional and had been withdrawn in subsequent policy decisions:

“The recognition granted to the IME’s certification by the Government of India was withdrawn in 2002 and subsequently reviewed. The decision to cease recognition after 2013 is legally valid.”

4. Limited Exception for Pre-2013 Enrollments

The Court provided relief for students who had enrolled in IME’s program before May 31, 2013:

“Students who enrolled with IME before May 31, 2013, will be considered eligible for employment in Central Government services, as per the 2012 and 2017 notifications.”

Final Verdict

The Supreme Court ruled:

The IME membership certificate is not equivalent to a degree in Mechanical Engineering.
Government recognition for IME’s certification ceased after May 31, 2013.
Students who enrolled before the cutoff date will continue to be eligible for government jobs under previous policies.
The appeal by IME was dismissed, and the High Court’s ruling was upheld.

Conclusion

This ruling reinforces the authority of AICTE and UGC in regulating technical education in India. It clarifies that institutions offering professional certifications cannot claim equivalence with formally recognized engineering degrees. The decision ensures that only accredited engineering qualifications are accepted for employment in government services, protecting educational standards and the credibility of technical education.

Petitioner Name: Institution of Mechanical Engineers (India).
Respondent Name: State of Punjab & Ors..
Judgment By: Justice Uday Umesh Lalit, Justice Deepak Gupta.
Place Of Incident: Punjab.
Judgment Date: 13-08-2019.

Don’t miss out on the full details! Download the complete judgment in PDF format below and gain valuable insights instantly!

Download Judgment: Institution of Mecha vs State of Punjab & Or Supreme Court of India Judgment Dated 13-08-2019.pdf

Direct Downlaod Judgment: Direct downlaod this Judgment

See all petitions in Recruitment Policies
See all petitions in Public Sector Employees
See all petitions in Education Related Cases
See all petitions in Judgment by Uday Umesh Lalit
See all petitions in Judgment by Deepak Gupta
See all petitions in dismissed
See all petitions in Declared Infructuous
See all petitions in supreme court of India judgments August 2019
See all petitions in 2019 judgments

See all posts in Service Matters Category
See all allowed petitions in Service Matters Category
See all Dismissed petitions in Service Matters Category
See all partially allowed petitions in Service Matters Category